Why Most Marketing Agencies Fall Short—and How to Pick the Right One for Your Painting Business

How a Painting Company Turned $2,700 in Facebook Ads Into $32,500 in Sales

June 13, 20254 min read

At Taurify, we help painting companies grow fast — but not by guessing. We use clear, data-backed strategies that deliver results. One of our clients, Pure Painting, recently brought in $32,500 in closed jobs from just $2,700 in Facebook ad spend.

That’s a 12x return on ad spend (ROAS).

In this article, we’ll walk through exactly how we set up that winning campaign — from targeting, to creative, to lead handling, and the secret ingredient that ties it all together: speed and follow-up.

Let’s dive in.


Step 1: Start With Smart Targeting

Before we launched a single ad, we worked with Pure Painting to identify their ideal audience. Since they’re based in Jackson, Michigan, we targeted higher-income neighborhoods — places where homeowners are more likely to afford quality painting services.

💡 Tip: If you're running Facebook ads in a big metro area, narrow your targeting to high-income ZIP codes. For example, in Los Angeles, consider Orange County.

We also filtered by age (30 or 35+), which usually ensures you're reaching homeowners — not renters or young adults unlikely to need professional painters.


Step 2: Use Authentic, Personable Ads

Here’s where things get powerful.

In the ad creatives, we featured Eric, the business owner, and his family. These weren’t overproduced videos — just real people, introducing themselves and their work. When leads later saw Eric in person for an estimate, they already felt like they knew him.

📸 Image Recommendation: Use friendly, high-quality images of the business owner or team at work. A smiling face in uniform can build instant trust.

The idea is simple: people buy from people, not faceless brands. Making your team the face of your company builds familiarity and trust before you even pick up the phone.


Step 3: Convert Leads Fast with CRM + Speed-to-Lead

Getting leads is only half the battle. What matters most is how you follow up.

Pure Painting used DripJobs, a contractor-friendly CRM, to automatically manage leads, schedule estimates, and track pipeline value. If you’re not using a CRM, we strongly recommend getting one in place.

💡 Pro Tip: Use tools like DripJobs to automate follow-ups and proposals. If you want to try it out, use code T60 for a 60-day free trial.

But automation alone isn’t enough. The real game-changer was speed. Every new lead was called within 5 minutes, no matter the day — even weekends.

We handled this with our in-house appointment setting team, available 7 days a week, 14 hours a day. That way, no opportunity slipped through the cracks.

📞 Want to DIY? Train your admin or hire after-hours support. Most quality leads come after work hours.


Step 4: Focus on Booking the Estimate — Not Just the Lead

Leads don’t equal money — appointments do.

We helped Pure Painting hit a 58% appointment set rate, which means nearly 6 out of 10 leads were scheduled for an estimate. We aim for at least 30% set rates with all our clients.

Why does this matter? Because if you're only setting 10–20% of your leads into actual appointments, you're leaving money on the table.


Step 5: Close the Sale With Confidence

Eric, the owner of Pure Painting, didn’t stop at ads — he invested in sales coaching and training.

That allowed him to close at 28.2%, meaning roughly 1 in 3 estimates turned into a paying customer. That’s where the real profit is made.

We always say:

Ads bring the leads, but sales close the deals.

Even if you just improve your closing rate by 5%, that can mean tens of thousands in added revenue over the year.


Recap: The Winning System

Here’s the breakdown of Pure Painting’s success:

  • $2,700 spent on Facebook Ads

  • 93 leads generated

  • 60 estimates booked

  • $32,500 in closed jobs from ads

  • $43,000 total in sales

  • $38,000 more in pipeline jobs pending

These results aren’t magic — they’re built on a clear process:

  1. Target the right audience

  2. Use authentic, personable ad creatives

  3. Follow up fast (within 5 minutes)

  4. Book estimates, not just leads

  5. Close strong with a sales system


Want Help Doing This for Your Business?

If you’re a painting business owner who’s serious about growth, this is what we do at Taurify — every single day.

We run the ads. We book the appointments. We help you close the deals.

If you’re ready to stop guessing and start growing, book a free strategy call with our team today. We’ll show you exactly what’s working for other painting businesses like yours — and how we can do the same for you.


Let’s grow your painting business the smart way. Book a call today.

Click here to book a call with our team


Watch this on YouTube

l


Painting BusinessesLead GenerationPainting business marketing agency
Back to Blog